Free agency is right around the corner, so let’s rank the top nine available offensive linemen on the open market, or at least the ones with the potential to make it there. We will start at the bottom and work our way to No. 1.
Top 9 Free Agent Offensive Linemen
9. Isaiah Wynn, OT, New England Patriots
Isaiah Wynn, a former first-round pick from Georgia, flashes a ton of athleticism and a lot of pass-blocking prowess. He’s really good when pulling out into space, but it just hasn’t come together for him with the New England Patriots. He battled some injuries this past year and missed eight games. They switched him to the right side, which didn’t go quite as well.
Wynn has plenty of talent and the ability to be successful. If he goes to a team where he feels more comfortable, meshes better with the coaching staff, and stays healthy, he could be a valuable player. This league is about throwing the ball and protecting the quarterback, and he does that at a pretty high level.
8. Kaleb McGary, OT, Atlanta Falcons
Kaleb McGary had a really strong 2022 season, which was bolstered by the Atlanta Falcons‘ offensive scheme. He was a tremendous run blocker in their heavy outside zone scheme. It’s a fun offense to play in, but it makes offensive linemen look better.
I benefited from that when I blocked for Kyle Shanahan, and it’s become a trend with those offenses that rely a lot on the outside zone and the play action. McGary has been a decent player. The weakest part of his game has been pass-blocking. That took a step up this past season, both because of the offense and because he’s improved.
7. Jermaine Eluemunor, OT, Las Vegas Raiders
Jermaine Eluemunor has been a good player for a while. He was an occasional starter with the Patriots for a few years. He played all the positions well, but he finally got a starting job for the Las Vegas Raiders this past season. Eluemunor struggled in a couple of early games, but he settled into his role nicely and finished strong.
He doesn’t quite look like an offensive tackle. He’s a little bit shorter (6-foot-4), he’s a little bit stouter (345), but he plays the position well. Eluemunor has a ton of leverage and is super strong, allowing him to move defenders off the ball in the running game. In the passing game, he’s stout at the point of attack if a defender tries to bull-rush him, and he’s got the lateral ability to mirror rushers.
6. Andrew Wylie, OT, Kansas City Chiefs
Andrew Wylie is criminally underrated. I know exactly what that position is asked to do in the Kansas City Chiefs offense. Wylie’s done a pretty good job of handling it. If you look at a few of the games he hasn’t performed well, you’ll see a mixture of things that went into that.
No. 1, he ran into a string of top-tier, if not Hall of Fame pass rushers. He went against Nick Bosa, Joey Bosa, Maxx Crosby and Von Miller in about a five-week stretch, so there will be a couple of bad reps, which is OK. We all have bad reps, and Wylie is going to keep fighting. He’s equally good in the run game and the passing game.
You know what you’ll get out of Wylie at this point, which is a valuable thing to have in the locker room and on the field.
5. Jawaan Taylor, OT, Jacksonville Jaguars
I’ve always loved Jawaan Taylor‘s game, partly because he had my former offensive line coach, George Walker, coaching him. So maybe there is a little bit of bias in that perspective because I see all the same pass sets and techniques I used to take. He has been a good player for the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Taylor utilizes a vertical set, which can look a little funky and be a little bit off-putting for people that aren’t used to it. He’s pretty good in pass protection, which is important as an offensive tackle.
Taylor can move defenders off the ball in the running game. He is competitive enough to be a well-rounded player. One team will be pretty lucky to sign him.
4. Mike McGlinchey, OT, San Francisco 49ers
Mike McGlinchey was billed coming out of Notre Dame as a sturdy, steady offensive lineman with an elite frame and athleticism. It hasn’t quite all come together as expected during his time with the San Francisco 49ers. Now, it’s not fair to compare him to Zack Martin or Quenton Nelson, but those are the guys that he played with in college.
McGlinchey has turned into a solid offensive tackle in San Francisco’s scheme. He gets bolstered a little bit because he’s not asked to do as much drawback protection. He’s not asked to do the hard stuff quite as often as other teams. When healthy, he’s progressed and improved his game over the past few years. Health is one of McGlinchey’s concerns, along with consistency in pass protection.
Any team that signs him will get a good run blocker and someone who is pretty well-rounded.
3. Isaac Seumalo, OG, Philadelphia Eagles
We spent all season talking about how great that Philadelphia Eagles offensive line was, and Isaac Seumalo is right up there with Lane Johnson and Jason Kelce. Plus, he happened to play between them, which was pretty nice for Philadelphia. Seumalo, who went to Oregon State, has been a good player for a while who has improved every single season.
Since he’s from the Philadelphia offensive line, you know what you’re getting. They’re going to be tough. They’re going to be physical. They’re going to know how to run every single scheme — inside zone, outside zone, blocking down, pulling trap blocks, power. Anything you could ask of an offensive lineman in the run game, he’s going to have done and done it at a high level.
His pass-blocking ability is good enough to stifle the Aaron Donald– and Chris Jones-type game-wreckers. We saw him do that against Jones in the Super Bowl.
He’s one of the top guys in this class. For me, he’s the top guard.
2. Orlando Brown, OT, Kansas City Chiefs
Orlando Brown has been to four Pro Bowls in a row and just won a Super Bowl. His situation is interesting because last year it seemed like he was gunning for that top-of-the-market left tackle money. The Chiefs weren’t willing to do that so they placed the franchise tag on him when they couldn’t figure out a long-term deal.
When you look at the truly elite guys, Trent Williams, Tyron Smith (when he’s healthy) and David Bakhtiari (when he’s healthy), Brown comes in under that group. But the next guy up typically gets the highest contract. That’s where the standstill comes in because if you’re not necessarily the elite of the elite, but it’s free agency time, you tend to get paid as the next highest guy. So he’s in the right asking for a lucrative deal.
It seems like the Chiefs did their best to sign him to a long-term deal, even though they won’t tag him again this year. Brown is going to make a lot of money. He’s been a mainstay there for two years. He played right tackle with the Baltimore Ravens and left tackle with Kansas City. You know what you’re getting: a solid player who is good in the run and pass games.
He has some limitations because of his size and athleticism. But he understands how to use that big frame, and the Chiefs want to keep that pocket nice and clear and allow Patrick Mahomes to step up. Brown allows them to do that.
1. Jason Kelce, C, Philadelphia Eagles
Should Jason Kelce be on this list? Is he a true free agent? There’s no chance he’s going anywhere other than Philadelphia or into some sort of studio as an analyst if he retires. But he is on the list because he is a free agent coming into this year. He’s the best offensive lineman that could be available, however unlikely that is.
He’s 35. He’s 6-foot-3 and doesn’t even weigh 300 pounds, but he’s still an awesome player. He can run block, pass block, everything you could want. He looks like a running back when he gets out in space. It’s incredible to watch how a smaller lineman can move defenders off the ball to create leverage.
If you want to understand how offensive line play works, how leverage works, and how you can overcome a size deficit just watch Kelce. He plays the game the best way that he can — with physicality, leverage and smarts.
He does everything he can in the passing game, calling out protections. So, he’s on top of really every facet of the offense. Having a center that can do all those things is so valuable.
Plus, on fourth-and-1 and third-and-1, what are the Eagles going to do? QB sneak. And everyone talks about, “Oh, it’s so easy.”
But Philly’s doing it the best we’ve ever seen in NFL history. Kelce is the guy snapping, and he’s at the point of that blocking scheme. So, you can put a lot into your offense because you have Kelce there. For that reason, he’s my top free-agent offensive lineman heading into the 2023 NFL offseason.
Mitchell Schwartz is a former NFL All-Pro offensive tackle who played nine seasons with the Cleveland Browns and Kansas City Chiefs. He was a member of the Chiefs’ Super Bowl LIV-winning team. Follow him on Twitter at @MitchSchwartz71.
